Seller reviews

4.9 average · 312 sales · since 2019

4.9(312 reviews)

5★

295

4★

3★

2★

1★

marcellinep
Mar 2026
on Cast iron skillet, pre-seasoned (estate)
Heavy, well-loved pan. Seasoned beautifully. Cornbread came out perfect on the first try.
j_burroughs
Mar 2026
on Set of 4 milk-glass tumblers
All four arrived without a chip. Wrapped with real care. Will buy from this seller again.
willowandoak
Feb 2026
on Crocheted afghan blanket, granny squares
Lovely colors, much softer than I expected. Looks beautiful on the back of the reading chair.
deannak
Feb 2026
on Pyrex casserole dish with lid, 1970s
Exactly the pattern my grandmother had. Shipping was quick and it was packed in two layers of bubble wrap.
T. Halvorsen
Feb 2026
on Boy's denim jacket, size 6, patched elbow
This jacket belonged to my son Leo. He went missing from Hollow Pine in 2009. I do not know how this seller has it. The left elbow patch was sewn on by his grandmother — I would know that stitching anywhere. There is a smear of green crayon inside the right pocket that he put there. I am asking — please — for the seller, or anyone who reads this, to contact the Coos County Sheriff's Office. I am not leaving a star. I cannot.
⚑ Flagged for review · Seller has not responded
cordeliareads
Feb 2026
on Stack of Reader's Digest condensed books (12)
Great condition for their age. A nice little library starter. Bookplates inside are charming.
thriftygran
Jan 2026
on Embroidered tea towels, set of 3
Sweet hand-embroidered birds on each one. Some light staining as described, nothing a soak didn't help.
merrowmade
Jan 2026
on Brass candlesticks, pair
Beautiful patina. They look gorgeous on the mantel. Seller polished them just enough — not too shiny.
ofcr. r. tully (cc so)
Jan 2026
on Coil of weathered rope, approx. 30 ft
This listing was purchased by the Coos County Sheriff's Office in connection with an open cold-case file. Fiber analysis has been requested and a hold has been placed on case CCSO-2019-0114. Seller is requested to preserve all remaining inventory and contact this office immediately. Removing the star is not personal. Item arrived intact and well packed.
⚑ Flagged for review · Seller has not responded
petalandpine
Dec 2025
on Box of vintage Christmas ornaments (mercury glass)
Every single one wrapped individually. None broken. They're going straight on the tree this year.
ms_lindgren
Dec 2025
on Hand-painted wooden duck decoy
Charming folk piece. Paint is worn in all the right places. Sitting on my bookshelf now.
anders.h
Nov 2025
on Singer sewing machine, 1952, working
Runs like a dream. Smooth stitch. The case has some scuffs but the machine itself is in lovely shape.
thequietshelf
Nov 2025
on Pressed-flower botanical, framed
Such a delicate piece. Came in a sturdy box with corner protectors. Hanging in the entryway already.
rosalindp
Nov 2025
on Crock pot, harvest gold, 1970s
Works perfectly. Arrived clean and ready to use. Did a pot roast in it the day it came.
millhouse_finds
Oct 2025
on Set of mason jars with zinc lids (dozen)
All twelve intact, lids in great shape. Perfect for my canning project. Thank you!

Showing 15 of 312. Older reviews archived.